Now that the pesky matter of her grandpa's "shotgun situation" is behind them, Maggie May Carver is ready to get on with settling down in Baker Valley, Colorado with her Newfie, Miss Fancypants. Unfortunately, when Maggie's nemesis, Janice Fletcher, is found dead, Maggie is the main suspect. Actually, she's the only suspect. Now, whether she wants to or not, Maggie has to find the real killer before she's locked up for life.

Just when things are starting to settle into a nice little routine, Maggie finds herself once more tracking down a murderer. One she hopes isn't her best (and only) customer. Add to that the little complication of Matt's brother coming to town—a man who's a deadly dangerous combination of Matt's good looks and Lucas Dean's charm—and Maggie has her hands full. That's alright. With her trusty Newfie Miss Fancypants at her side, there isn't a murder Maggie can't solve. No matter how much she'd rather be eating cinnamon rolls instead.